Fish, water and sediment quality as indicators of land-use change in the Steelpoort River (Olifants River System, Limpopo Province)

Abstract

This study aimed to determine the effects of water and sediment quality on fish and the effects of land-use on the water and sediment quality of the Steelpoort River system. To achieve these aims, a few objectives had to be met. The water and sediment quality, the level of metal bioaccumulation of two fish species, the level of acetylcholine esterase inhibition in fish brain tissue, as well as changes in land-use over time. The study adds value in the scientific knowledge of the Steelpoort catchment given that there’s little information about it. It is thus a good baseline, which gives direction for further studies conducted within this catchment. The Steelpoort River, is a tributary of the Olifants River system. The Olifants River (Mpumalanga and Limpopo provinces) is a river stressed by anthropogenic activities with the Steelpoort River being a major sub-catchment. The Steelpoort catchment is filled with mines, agricultural activities, and other developments, such as, the construction of a new dam (De Hoop Dam opened 2014), residential areas and malls. The mines within the catchment are mostly platinum and chrome mines. Sampling was conducted for high and low flow at five sampling sites: Two upstream sites, 1 and 2, and three downstream sites 3, 4, and 5. Site 1 is the reference site for the study as this section (ecoregion) was described as “least threatened”. It was hypothesised that high concentrations of metals and nutrients would be present in the water and sediment, and that the metal would be present in fish tissue and would have an effect on human health, that the biomarker AChE would show signs of inhibition within brain tissue, and lastly that land-use characteristics would have an effect on the water and sediment quality, and inhibition of AChE. Water and sediment samples were collected quarterly over a period of a year at five sites, whereas fish samples (Chiloglanis pretoriae and Labeobarbus marequensis) were only collected bi-annually at three sites. The physico-chemical, nutrients, cations and ions, and metals and metalloids were determined. The two fish species were used for metal bioaccumulation and AChE analyses. Human health risk and bio-concentration factor (BCF) analyses were conducted. Using the land-cover details obtained from South African National Biodiversity Institute (SANBI), Department of Environmental Affairs (DEA) and The Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), land-use characteristics were determined and evaluated. The in-situ physico-chemical parameters assessed in this study were found to be within acceptable limits of the Target Water Quality Range (TWQR) at all the sites. The Electrical Confuctivity (EC) and Total Disolved Solids (TDS) parameters were highest at Site 5 and lowest at Site 1, this could be due to Site 5 being the last site before the Steelpoort River connects to the Olifants River, hence this site recieves all the ions and solutes from upstream; and the lowest value at Site 1 could be attributed to this site having the least number of lan-use effects. For nutrients, the highest total nitrogen concentration was recorded at Site 5 and the highest phosphate concentration at Site. This river is mesotrophic according to both the total inorganic nitrogen and phosphorus levels. Metals in the water column that were above DWAF guidelines for Aquatic Ecosystems were Al, Ba, Mn and Zn. In the sediment the following metals were above the Canadian sediment quality guidelines: Cd, Cu, Cr and Zn, which can pose a threat to the health of fish through biomagnification through the food chain. Both C. pretoriae and L. marequensis had bioaccumulated metals from the river system. The concentrations of metals in the muscle tissue of C. pretoriae where higher and this could be due to the fact that unskinned samples were used in the case of C. pretoriae. A variety of metals were present in both fish species but Al, Fe, Sr and Zn were present in higher concentrations. Concentrations of metals were highest in samples from Site 5 The human health risk assessment revealed that Pb could cause health related impacts to the humans who consume a single 150 g fish meal once a week in C. pretoriae; and that Co could cause potential risks in the near future. The BCF values revealed that there were more bioconcentrated metals in C. pretoriae than in L. marequensis and this could also be due to different diets. The AChE activity was higher for L. marequensis during high flow at all sites and higher at Site 1 during low flow but lower at Site 5 and equivalent at Site 2 than the AChE activity recorded for C. pretoriae. This could be due to the ability of L. marequensis to expel pesticides from their system before the pesticides affect brain activity by decreasing the function of AChE. Both fish species had more AChE activity during low flow for sites 1 and 2 than during high flow. The high flow AChE activity was higher for Site 5 in both fish species. The results confirm the hypotheses were that metals would be present in fish tissue and would have an effect on human health; and that the biomarker AChE would show signs of inhibition within brain tissue. The agricultural activity has decreased over time within the catchment, from 2000 to 2014 and this could be due to a decrease of fertile land. There has also been a decrease in the mining activity from 2000 to 2009 and then an increase during 2014, where the decrease could be due to the closure of mines at the end of their life span; and the increase in 2014 could be due to the opening of new mines. Residential areas have increased from 2000 through to 2014. The availability of water decreased from 2000 to 2009, and then increased drastically in 2014. The drastic increase is due to the multiple dams that have been built over time in order to provide water resources to the increased population, and also for mining and irrigation purposes. The water quality showed an increase in the NO3, SO4 and PO4; meanwhile the EC has decreased over time. The decrease in EC means that there are fewer ions in the river. The increase in phosphates and nitrates could mean there is a lot of fertilizers and pesticides being used in agriculture even with the decrease in agricultural land-use over the years. The pesticides can also be due to the increase in residential areas, where pesticides are also used to get rid of pests.